ACCFIN COMPANY LAW
Guide
×
  (c) Company name, 2024

S48(8) READ TOGETHER WITH S114

What makes a buyback a fundamental transaction under s114 as section 48(8) has dropped the 5% rule.
A buyback (repurchase) of shares can still qualify as a fundamental transaction under Section 114 of the Companies Act, 71 of 2008, even though Section 48(8) no longer explicitly applies the 5% rule. Here's an explanation:
1. Section 114 - Fundamental Transactions
Section 114 governs specific transactions deemed "fundamental" because they significantly impact the structure or control of the company. A share buyback becomes a fundamental transaction under Section 114(1)(e) if it results in a scheme of arrangement.
A scheme of arrangement is defined as:
  • An arrangement between the company and its shareholders (or a class of shareholders) that results in significant structural changes, such as altering shareholding or shareholder rights.
In the case of a share buyback, if the transaction is:
  • Part of a negotiated arrangement with shareholders (e.g., targeting specific shareholders for the buyback, which could alter control, voting rights, or ownership structure),
  • It may trigger the requirements of Section 114.
2. Section 48 - Share Buybacks
Previously, Section 48(8) created a threshold of 5% of issued shares. If the buyback involved more than 5% of the issued shares, it would automatically trigger the need for compliance with Section 114. With the removal of the 5% rule, Section 48 no longer explicitly ties buybacks to fundamental transaction rules, leaving the determination of whether a buyback is a fundamental transaction to the specifics of each case.
3. When Does a Buyback Trigger Section 114?
Without the 5% rule, a buyback could trigger Section 114 if:
  • It is effectively a scheme of arrangement, as explained above.
  • The transaction significantly affects the company's capital structure or shareholder rights. This might happen in situations like:
  • A buyback from a specific group of shareholders that consolidates control in the hands of remaining shareholders.
  • A buyback that results in changes to voting rights, dividend entitlements, or other shareholder privileges.
4. Steps to Ensure Compliance
If a buyback triggers Section 114 as a fundamental transaction, the company must:
1. Obtain a report by an independent expert on the terms and fairness of the transaction (Section 114(3)).
2. Gain approval through a special resolution passed by shareholders (Section 115).
3. Allow dissenting shareholders to exercise their appraisal rights under Section 164, enabling them to demand payment for their shares at fair value.
Conclusion
Even though the 5% rule in Section 48(8) has been dropped, a share buyback can still qualify as a fundamental transaction under Section 114 if it meets the definition of a scheme of arrangement or has a significant structural impact on the company. Each transaction must be assessed on its own facts to determine whether it triggers the fundamental transaction provisions.
_____________________________________________________
The recent amendments to the Companies Act, 71 of 2008, have notably impacted the treatment of share buybacks and their classification as fundamental transactions under Section 114. Previously, Section 48(8)(b) stipulated that if a company repurchased more than 5% of its issued shares, the transaction was subject to the requirements of Sections 114 and 115, effectively categorizing it as a fundamental transaction. This provision has been removed, leading to significant changes in the regulatory landscape.
Key Changes:
1. Removal of the 5% Threshold:
  • The deletion of Section 48(8)(b) means that share buybacks exceeding 5% of the issued shares are no longer automatically subjected to the stringent requirements of Sections 114 and 115. This change aims to simplify the process for companies undertaking substantial share repurchases.
    Go Legal
    2. Implications for Share Buybacks:
  • Without the automatic classification under the previous 5% rule, companies must now assess each share buyback on a case-by-case basis to determine if it constitutes a fundamental transaction. Factors to consider include the nature of the buyback, its impact on the company's shareholding structure, and whether it involves arrangements that could be deemed a scheme of arrangement under Section 114.
    FWB Law
    3. Procedural Requirements:
  • For buybacks that do fall under Section 114, companies are required to:
  • Appoint an independent expert to compile a report on the proposed transaction.
  • Obtain approval through a special resolution passed by shareholders.
  • Provide dissenting shareholders with appraisal rights under Section 164.
Conclusion:
The removal of the 5% rule under Section 48(8)(b) necessitates a more nuanced analysis of share buybacks to determine their classification under Section 114. Companies must carefully evaluate the specifics of each transaction to ensure compliance with the Act's provisions and to ascertain whether the procedural requirements associated with fundamental transactions are applicable.
For a more detailed discussion on this topic, you may refer to the following articles:
  • "Share Buy-Backs: A discussion on the current legal framework and the changes considered in the Companies Amendment Bills."
    FWB Law
  • "The Companies Amendment Bill 2023: Key changes."
    Go Legal
  • "Share Repurchases, Schemes of Arrangement and the Takeover Regulations."
    Werksmans Attorneys
These resources provide comprehensive insights into the implications of the recent amendments and their impact on share buybacks and fundamental transactions.
Name the parameters that would force a buyback under s48(8) to s114 as a fundamental transaction.
The parameters that would force a share buyback under Section 48(8) to fall under Section 114 as a fundamental transaction (even with the removal of the 5% rule) involve considerations related to the nature and impact of the transaction. Here's a detailed list of the key parameters:
1. Nature of the Buyback - Scheme of Arrangement
  • Section 114(1)(e): A buyback may be classified as a scheme of arrangement if:
  • It involves a negotiated agreement with one or more shareholders.
  • The transaction fundamentally alters the rights or obligations of shareholders (e.g., differing classes of shares, voting rights, or ownership percentages).
2. Impact on Ownership Structure
  • A buyback that significantly changes the control or voting power within the company can be classified as a fundamental transaction. Examples include:
  • Buyback from a majority shareholder: This could lead to a shift in control or concentrated power among remaining shareholders.
  • Substantial reduction in public float: For listed companies, this may affect the shareholding base and market dynamics.
3. Procedural Complexity
  • If the buyback requires shareholder approval via a special resolution under Section 115, it is more likely to be categorized as a fundamental transaction.
4. Involvement of a Regulated Scheme
  • If the buyback triggers provisions of Section 118 (Takeover Regulations), such as:
  • The buyback involving related or interdependent transactions that fall under regulatory scrutiny.
  • The company being subject to the Takeover Regulations Panel’s oversight due to the magnitude or nature of the buyback.
5. Financial and Legal Thresholds
  • A buyback that affects the company’s capital structure, solvency, or liquidity may attract scrutiny under Section 114. This includes:
  • Transactions funded by significant debt or which materially impact the company's financial health.
  • A reduction in share capital that disrupts shareholder equity or distributions.
6. Shareholder Rights and Appraisal
  • If the buyback grants dissenting shareholders appraisal rights under Section 164, this suggests that the transaction impacts shareholder interests sufficiently to qualify as a fundamental transaction.
7. Targeted Shareholders
  • Selective Buybacks (rather than proportional or open-market repurchases) may require compliance with Section 114 if:
  • Certain shareholders receive preferential treatment.
  • Specific shareholder rights (e.g., preferential shares) are extinguished or altered.
8. Multiple Case Law and Context-Specific Triggers
  • The courts and legal interpretations may also classify a buyback as fundamental based on:
  • The cumulative effect of transactions that collectively meet the Section 114 threshold.
  • The company's articles of incorporation or shareholder agreements that impose additional requirements.
Conclusion
Even with the removal of the 5% rule in Section 48(8), a buyback can trigger Section 114 if it involves:
1. A scheme of arrangement,
2. Significant structural changes (ownership or control),
3. A need for shareholder approval under Section 115,
4. Procedural obligations like fairness opinions or Takeover Panel involvement.
Each buyback must be evaluated on its facts, considering its impact on the company and its shareholders.
 
Made with help of Dr.Explain